Tuesday, May 7, 2019

The Benevolent Atheist

I saw this on the /r/Atheism subreddit
If an Atheist is a good person, will they go to heaven or hell? If hell, then I don't believe in a God that punishes good people for eternity.  If heaven, then what's the point of believing in God?
Another way to ask this would be:
What gets a person into heaven, being good or believing in God?

Of course, the original poster wasn't interested in this answer.  It was really a use of logical fallacy to justify being an atheist.  Still, both questions are pointless since atheist don't believe in an afterlife.  For a meaningful debate, it's important to frame a question within bounds of shared beliefs and assumptions.  For example, both atheist and theist should agree to these points:
  • There is some universal measure of being good (kindness, do no harm, show respect, etc.)
  • The world is a better place if people are good
  • We are born into this world
  • While we are alive, we behave with some level of goodness
  • After we die, we cannot measurably act on this world or the people in it

So our new question with shared understanding is:
What is more likely to influence a person to be good while alive, being an atheist or believing in God?

There may be the standout "benevolent atheist" or "wicked theist", but what about a million people? Would they collectively be more benevolent as atheists or theists?

That is a worthwhile debate. 

An interesting post on the same subreddit

Sunday, May 5, 2019

I'm Always Late

Why am I late?

  • I really didn't want to go, but obligation kept nagging at me until I finally pulled it together and went.
  • I schedule my activities too close together (I can mow the lawn, put on an extra coat of paint, shower, get ready and drive through uncertain traffic to the event;  all in one hour because each activity only takes about 15 minutes).  I didn't account for time to transition between events (setup, cleanup, etc).
  • I always like what I am doing more than anything else.  That's because to do something else, I need to clean up what I am doing and then prepare for the other activity.  This can involve a change of clothes, set of tools, etc.  Another aspect is that we always have a simulation running in our brain.  Sometimes it can take a while to boot-up that simulation, so powering it down and firing up a new one can seem like too much work.    
I once talked with a wise elderly lady who told me that she would rather be an hour early than five minutes late.  There is great wisdom in this.  Some examples:
  • Flying on an airplane (missing a flight by even 10 seconds has painful consequences)
  • The birth of a child (I had a childhood friend that was born in the back seat).
  • A movie (I missed the rolling opening story for the first Star Wars movie and was confused for years on what the story was).
  • A job interview
  • A court hearing (I was a week late once.  The judge wasn't very merciful)
What have I done about this?
  • Don't cram activities together.  Enjoy a little peaceful time between events.  In our sometimes hectic life, this down time can be quite pleasant.
  • Follow the principle "on time instead of in time".  With "on time" you have a chance to fully transition to the activity with a buffer to account for unexpected obstacles.  With "in time", your heart is still racing as you take your seat, distracted by the trauma of trying to make it "in time".
  • Imagine the good things about an activity you don't want to go to.  I didn't want to go to a funeral once, thought about the people I hadn't seen for a while, and then had a life changing experience as a result.